To content To search Skip navigation

Navigation

Market breadth is declining – stock picking instead of index investing

Rising interest rates on one hand, rising corporate earnings on the other – in the equity market, opportunity and risk currently lie close together. However, because market breadth is declining, investors should now exercise caution.

September 2026 – The decision is sensible, yet it came as a surprise: the US Federal Reserve has raised key interest rates. In mid-September, rates rose by 0.25 percentage points to a range of now 3.75 to 4 percent. The hike is justified because inflation in the US has risen significantly for some time. In August, it stood at 3.6 percent, matching the previous month. Critics warn of inflation becoming entrenched, which could have significant negative impacts on consumption in the medium term. Nevertheless, the hike is highly controversial, especially in politics. Leading the charge, US President Donald Trump reacted aggressively and suspects a conspiracy – understandable, as his popularity among Americans is clearly waning. This presents a major problem, as the midterm elections are approaching in November. Although voting is not directly for the office of the US President, but rather for the composition of the Senate and the House of Representatives, the midterms are regarded as an important litmus test for Trump's policies. Rising interest rates, however sensible they may be, do not fare well in such an environment.

That is one side of the story. On the other hand, despite growing uncertainties for the equity market, many companies in the US are currently convincing with strong numbers and outlooks. The second-quarter earnings season in the US was one of the best in recent decades. Earnings in the S&P 500 are around 50 percent above the level of the second quarter of 2025. Although this strong increase is partly distorted by booking effects in the quarterly earnings of Alphabet and Amazon, even after adjusting for this influence, the earnings growth in the second quarter still stands at approximately 30 percent..

The "defenders" are becoming fewer
It is therefore obvious that US companies are doing well, which is also reflected in share prices. Benchmark indices such as the Dow Jones and the S&P 500 have reached record levels during the year, which they have been bravely defending for several months now. However, a development has recently emerged that should make investors more cautious: the market breadth of the "defenders" of these record levels is declining. The number of S&P stocks trading above their 200-day moving average has been declining significantly for some time. By mid-September, only about half of the S&P securities were trading above this level (see graph). By comparison, in July and August, over 70 percent of stocks were trading above their 200-day moving average.

The proportion of stocks participating in this "battle to defend records" is dwindling. For investors engaged in technical market analysis, this at least sets off alarm bells. A declining market breadth may signal the beginning of a correction in the overall market, which in this case would be the S&P 500..

Stock picking and portfolio hedging
For investors, it may therefore make sense now to focus more on stock picking rather than on the broad market. This also applies to the Swiss equity market, which in mid-September also showed declining market breadth, for instance in the Swiss Market Index (SMI). This weakness may not be permanent and could reverse, yet investors should react to it. In addition to stock picking, hedging existing portfolio positions is also conceivable.

To hedge your portfolio, we offer Mini-Shorts and Knock-Out Warrant Puts on the S&P 500 and the SMI, among other products.

-> Back to the MARKETS & CERTIFICATES focus overview page

The information offered on this website corresponds to marketing material pursuant to Article 68 of the Swiss Federal Act on Financial Services (FinSA) and serves exclusively informational purposes. The information does not constitute an investment recommendation or advice and does not contain an offer or an invitation to make an offer. It is not permitted to reproduce any part of the content of this website in any way without our prior written consent, except for the creation of a single copy or extract exclusively for personal, non-commercial purposes.

Back to the top of the page